skills/pbakaus_impeccable
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/pbakaus/impeccable.git synced 2026-09-17 16:46:31 +03:00
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
cb56ed6c19a07329a9fa0cd4e657bee040156593
pbakaus_impeccable/docs/comp-fidelity-review-2026-08-17.json
T

580 lines
17 KiB
JSON
Raw Blame History

{
"date": "2026-08-17",
"reviewer": "pbakaus",
"method": "click-to-annotate side-by-side page: comp left, build right; pass/unsure/fail per sample; pin coordinates omitted here, notes kept",
"samples": {
"cf3-05-05-sol-branch-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"bad font",
"shape is different",
"asset has wrong bg color",
"button in wrong spot",
"mini shape on cover should not be there",
"text in the wrong place",
"paper rip texture missing",
"bottom menu entirely missing"
]
},
"cf3-05-05-sol-branch-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"good font, but bad line height",
"yua komiyama in wrong font size and too much spacing to heading)",
"button too far down, also too much spacing above",
"looks like sol tried to replace the music sheet with html? lots of stuff missing, squiggles etc...",
"shape is cut off on both sides, terrible treatment",
"soft cathedrals in the wrong spot, very small",
"that double shape appears again",
"bottom menu missing entirely"
]
},
"cf3-05-05-sol-branch-003": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"bad font",
"extra content not in comp",
"extra content not in comp (worse even, section kickers are banned)",
"terrible html/svg rendition of music sheet",
"shape cut off at the top, very different quality as original",
"cover missing texture, text in wrong spot",
"bottom menu entirely missing"
]
},
"cf3-05-05-sol-main-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "by far the worst of all of them in this niche",
"pins": [
"extra content",
"extra content",
"extra content",
"extra content (section kicker)",
"bad font, improvised font treatment",
"completely replaced style of listen button",
"completely different music sheet",
"terrible approximated shape",
"bad cover in wrong location, with wrong content",
"bottom menu missing"
]
},
"cf3-05-05-sol-main-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"improvised bad font and treatment (actually doesn't look bad, but fail because very different as the comp)",
"extra content",
"improvised button, not in comp",
"completely different music sheet",
"terrible shape",
"extra content",
"menu missing",
"extra shape and other content in the cover",
"extra content",
"extra content"
]
},
"cf3-05-05-sol-main-003": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"extra content",
"bad font, improvised",
"improvised button",
"completely different than music sheet notation",
"bad cut off shape",
"bad cover with wrong content in bad position",
"bottom menu entirely missing again"
]
},
"cf3-07-07-sol-branch-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"texture of red element entirely missing",
"text in wrong location",
"text size and font wrong, mirrored, and in the wrong location",
"missing from build",
"menu to tall in build",
"menu dividers don't exist in comp",
"line way too low, too much spacing above",
"text cut off on the side. bolded parts don't exist in comp",
"button too far below, again too much spacing above",
"wrong icon",
"bad svg approximation",
"missing card containment, and bad positioning",
"label is outside the box in comp",
"very weird font compared to comp",
"\"today\" is wrongly positioned (arguably could make more sense there, but still violates the contract; the user should decide in the next round)",
"terrible approximation of asset",
"lines don't point to the right thing",
"this graphic is so bad it's almost offensive",
"this whole bottom area is not visible in the build because the content above pushes it all down"
]
},
"cf3-07-07-sol-branch-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"content missing in build",
"wrong color, but arguably might be better (user decision; if the comp violates detector rules like contrast, maybe a stated second pass)",
"bad font (too thick) but at least roughly in the right place",
"nav area too tall",
"hallucinated dividers",
"font only ok, not great approximation",
"too much spacing (width)",
"card in wrong location (needs to be further up and to the left), and bad icon",
"terrible svg approximation of asset",
"line sticks out of its box",
"bad font (too thick)",
"label wrongly positioned, not out of the box",
"bad svg approximation of asset",
"this whole container is too wide, text wraps at completely different breakpoints",
"table text too small, looks quite a bit different",
"this top card doesn't sit in its own visual card, like in the comp",
"absolutely atrocious svg instead of asset",
"font on button too small"
]
},
"cf3-07-07-sol-branch-003": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"white borders (review artefact, since fixed)",
"this text was black in the comp",
"texture missing",
"bad font size",
"made up dividers",
"top nav too tall",
"invented section kicker",
"text size wrong, overall makes this heading way too short",
"service note box entirely missing",
"thread box missing",
"bad svg instead of asset",
"lines point nowhere",
"table is different, and some content missing",
"terrible svg"
]
},
"cf3-07-07-sol-main-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"this is basically an entirely different build!"
]
},
"cf3-07-07-sol-main-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"also entirely different build"
]
},
"cf3-07-07-sol-main-003": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"entirely different build"
]
},
"cf3-11-11-sol-branch-001": {
"verdict": "unsure",
"note": "mostly passing, but a bunch of nits",
"pins": [
"white letterboxing (review artefact)",
"different icons, and too small. also, some missing",
"right side legend is missing (arguably redundant, but it's in the comp)",
"bottom legend missing",
"different arrow style",
"no spacing",
"acknowledge button not present in comp",
"side tab borders are missing in the comp (these side tabs are legitimate: not rounded)",
"this legend is arguably a useful addition, but wasn't in the comp"
]
},
"cf3-11-11-sol-branch-002": {
"verdict": "unsure",
"note": "mostly pass, with nits",
"pins": [
"wrong icons again, and some missing",
"wrong dropdown style",
"wrong live style, no pause button",
"utc is above, but not in the comp",
"wrong label, and input not vertically centered",
"silenced is missing in the build",
"wrong arrow styles",
"invented box colors",
"font size too small",
"font size too small",
"lines are much less fuzzy (much less data points maybe?)",
"legend not in comp"
]
},
"cf3-11-11-sol-branch-003": {
"verdict": "unsure",
"note": "ok with nits",
"pins": [
"wrong dropdown style",
"these don't wrap on the comp",
"header too tall in build",
"best icons so far, mostly good",
"settings icon missing in build",
"help icon missing in build",
"text is overlapping lines",
"font size too small",
"font size too small (\"errors\")",
"these aren't in boxes with a border",
"hallucinated legend",
"hallucinated little squares",
"wrong arrow style"
]
},
"cf3-11-11-sol-main-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"bad menu",
"completely different looking chart structure",
"very different looking visualization",
"letterboxing (review artefact)",
"nav missing",
"hallucinated legend",
"hallucinated trend lines"
]
},
"cf3-11-11-sol-main-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "didn't leave annotations because very similarly bad to 001",
"pins": []
},
"cf3-11-11-sol-main-003": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "didn't leave annotations because very similarly bad to 001",
"pins": []
},
"cf4-05-05-opus-branch-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"shadow doesn't exist in comp",
"button too far down",
"music notation lines bleed into the album cover",
"bottom menu is entirely missing"
]
},
"cf4-05-05-opus-branch-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "this would be a pass if the black shape wouldnt have a horrible clipping bug",
"pins": [
"shape cropped at the left and bottom, looks like a bug",
"the paper rip effect is bolder than in the comp, but first time the details at the bottom actually come through, nice!"
]
},
"cf4-05-05-opus-main-001": {
"verdict": "pass",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"wrong bg color",
"text too cramped towards the top",
"mini arc within the cover",
"bad font size and position"
]
},
"cf4-05-05-opus-main-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"bad font",
"the grain is too heavy here",
"this shape should not go all the way to the bottom",
"these artifacts make no sense",
"mini arc should be there",
"wrong font size in the wrong place",
"music notes cut off",
"bottom menu missing"
]
},
"cf4-07-07-opus-branch-001": {
"verdict": "unsure",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"white instead of black",
"table style is off",
"line wrap is different",
"image is different",
"font is bad - bold",
"texture missing",
"white letterboxing (review artefact)",
"pretty good but looks a bit different",
"these stick out"
]
},
"cf4-07-07-opus-branch-002": {
"verdict": "unsure",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"white text, overlaps",
"the style of those components is very different, almost as if we didn't pass in the crop of the original or the prompt",
"this is flat on the comp",
"bad asset",
"whole index shown is hallucinated",
"font is too different, spacing between lines is too much"
]
},
"cf4-07-07-opus-main-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"text is wrongly positioned",
"bad asset",
"bad font weight",
"asset in diff style",
"asset in diff style",
"table is completely off",
"invented"
]
},
"cf4-07-07-opus-main-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"terrible font",
"table gone",
"bad heading",
"should be below button",
"hallucinated",
"hallucinated",
"bad layout",
"different copy",
"different copy"
]
},
"cf4-11-11-opus-branch-001": {
"verdict": "pass",
"note": "mostly nits, would give this a pass",
"pins": [
"slightly different dropdown styles",
"hallucinated side tab",
"icons smaller than in comp",
"table looks quite different",
"number is in the wrong place",
"font size too large",
"box style is slightly different",
"help icon missing"
]
},
"cf4-11-11-opus-main-001": {
"verdict": "unsure",
"note": "worse than branch, but also not terrible",
"pins": [
"hallucinated scope field",
"slow traces not in the original comp",
"table style and grid is different",
"help icon missing",
"icons a bit too small",
"active style looks different",
"button does not exist in comp",
"text not vertically aligned",
"search bar too long",
"background grid lines are missing",
"this chart area overall is too tall, pushes everything below further down",
"different box style, too tall boxes"
]
},
"cf4-11-11-opus-main-002": {
"verdict": "unsure",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"letterboxing (review artefact)",
"button doesn't exist in comp",
"chart area way too tall",
"box style different",
"logo not flush on the left",
"icons are too small",
"help icon missing"
]
},
"cf5-07-07-sol-branch-001": {
"verdict": "unsure",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"white instead of black text",
"font feels very off, too bold, not tall enough etc",
"texture missing",
"header divider line is much too far down",
"font too bold",
"line wrap here is terrible, not like in the comp",
"this is below the button in the comp",
"bad icon",
"text a bit too small",
"asset is badly positioned",
"text too bold",
"this whole thing is not in a visual box",
"looks like a weird crop",
"non-sensical lines that point nowhere",
"weird hallucinated buttons",
"table too small, font too small, looks different",
"asset looks too low res (like a crop), positioned badly, overflows at the top"
]
},
"cf5-07-07-sol-branch-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"letterboxing (review artefact)",
"black text at the bottom missing",
"font-size too small",
"should be below button",
"line height too low",
"hallucinated section kicker",
"hallucinated dividers",
"table entirely missing",
"terrible svg",
"weird divider",
"weird artifacts",
"service note box out of viewport",
"terrible svg",
"header too tall"
]
},
"cf5-07-07-sol-branch-003": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"letterboxing (review artefact)",
"bad divider lines",
"white instead of black text",
"texture missing",
"bottom text missing",
"hallucinated section kicker",
"red line too thick",
"weird bolding",
"service note icon bad, box missing, asset missing",
"cardinal clipping sins",
"terrible svg",
"terrible svg",
"hallucinated table header and color",
"table overflowing"
]
},
"cf6-05-05-sol-branch-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"bad section kicker",
"font too small",
"terrible approximation of music notation sheet",
"bottom row missing",
"bad bg color",
"terrible cover, double arc",
"weird white space",
"extra text",
"extra text",
"extra text"
]
},
"cf6-05-05-sol-branch-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"letter spacing way too wide",
"font size too small",
"pretty bad approximation of music notation sheet",
"bottom row missing",
"terrible cover asset",
"extra arc"
]
},
"cf6-05-05-sol-branch-003": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"bad font, but better than other passes",
"terrible approximation again of music notation",
"bad cover, but at least soft cathedrals is positioned correctly",
"arc shape is wrong and badly positioned",
"bottom row missing"
]
},
"cf6-07-07-sol-branch-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"texture missing",
"bad font, too small",
"bad font, comp is not bold at all in the header",
"too bold font",
"wraps on the wrong words",
"service note looks different, misses icon, text etc",
"stick out of the box",
"text overflows the container",
"font size way too large",
"bad asset crop (crops are never allowed)",
"bad asset crop (crops are never allowed) and badly positioned",
"lines overflowing, badly positioned",
"table header is comically tall",
"thread index is overlapping lines",
"'thread' label is within the box, not outside"
]
},
"cf6-07-07-sol-branch-002": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "dramatic fail. invented a completely different layout.",
"pins": []
},
"cf6-07-07-sol-branch-003": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"texture missing",
"font size too big",
"heading overflows on the right",
"bad line width",
"text overflows, box looks super different",
"asset terribly positioned",
"this whole thing is not in a visible bordered box anymore",
"non-sensical lines pointing to wrong things",
"asset has bad bg color",
"these elements are way too far below and unreadable"
]
},
"cf7-05-05-opus-branch-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "",
"pins": [
"button too far down",
"music notation ok but not perfect; doesn't flow into the arc shape on the right",
"font too small",
"arc shape cut off on the right and extending too far below",
"bottom row entirely missing"
]
},
"cf7-05-05-opus-branch-002": {
"verdict": "pass",
"note": "wow - by far the best result so far!",
"pins": [
"text not present in comp"
]
},
"cf7-07-07-opus-branch-001": {
"verdict": "fail",
"note": "absolutely insane fail. it's like a toddler sprinkled assets on a page",
"pins": []
},
"cf7-07-07-opus-branch-002": {
"verdict": "pass",
"note": "this is a borderline pass",
"pins": [
"white text instead of black",
"texture missing",
"bottom text way too far below",
"service note box way too far below",
"heading way more compressed (short) than in comp",
"label not on the left edge",
"line missing"
]
}
}
}
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink