Files
magnus919_agent-skills/org-design/references/compensation-frameworks.md
T
Magnus HedemarkandGitHub c7c4d3b74f Port 11 methodology skills from hermes-profiles (#69)
Engineering: backend-engineering, frontend-engineering, data-engineering,
ml-engineering, platform-engineering, qa-methodology

Executive: go-to-market, legal-strategy, operational-design, org-design,
product-strategy

ml-engineering: added missing training-infrastructure.md reference
qa-methodology: added test-data-management, performance-testing,
security-testing references

All frontmatter converted to agent-skills convention.
Source: https://github.com/magnus919/hermes-profiles
2026-07-21 00:58:26 -04:00

113 lines
5.8 KiB
Markdown

# Compensation Frameworks
## Market Benchmarking
### The Three Sources Approach
Cross-reference three sources to determine market pay:
| Source | Pros | Cons | Use for |
|--------|------|------|---------|
| **Radford/Aon** | Comprehensive tech data, global | Expensive, requires subscription | All tech roles |
| **Levels.fyi / Glassdoor** | Transparent, real-time | Self-reported, noisy | Benchmarking reality vs surveys |
| **Payscale / Compensation.com** | Broad coverage, good for non-tech | Less tech-specific | G&A, marketing, operations |
| **Industry-specific** (e.g., Culpepper) | Niche role coverage | Industry-specific only | Biotech, finance |
### Market Positioning Strategy
| Position | Definition | When to use |
|----------|------------|-------------|
| **P10** (lagging) | Below market median | Cost-constrained, non-core roles, non-competitive labor market |
| **P50** (market) | At market median | Standard positioning for most roles |
| **P75** (leading) | Above market median | Critical roles, hard-to-fill skills, competitive market |
| **P90** (premium) | Top of market | Executive talent, scarcity-driven roles, strategic hires |
### Geography Adjustments
Apply location-based multipliers to base pay:
| Location Tier | Multiplier (typical) | Examples |
|---------------|---------------------|----------|
| Tier 1 (Premium) | 1.0x (base) | San Francisco, NYC, London |
| Tier 2 (Major metro) | 0.85-0.95x | Seattle, Chicago, Berlin |
| Tier 3 (Secondary) | 0.75-0.85x | Austin, Denver, Dublin |
| Tier 4 (Remote/Rest) | 0.65-0.75x | Rural US, lower-cost regions |
**Remote-first trend:** Many companies are moving to location-independent pay or a single national band. Tradeoff: hiring efficiency vs compensation equity.
## Equity Design
### Equity Instruments
| Instrument | Description | Typical for |
|------------|-------------|-------------|
| **ISO** (Incentive Stock Options) | Tax-advantaged options, $100K/yr limit per employee | Employees at VC-backed companies |
| **NSO** (Non-Qualified Stock Options) | Standard options, no limit | Employees, contractors, advisors |
| **RSU** (Restricted Stock Units) | Actual shares vest over time | Public companies, late-stage private |
| **SAR** (Stock Appreciation Rights) | Cash payout equal to share appreciation | Private companies wanting option-like economics without dilution |
| **ESPP** (Employee Stock Purchase Plan) | Discounted stock purchase (typically 15%) | Public companies |
### Equity Grant Benchmarks
| Level | Grant range (% of pool) | Grant range ($ value, private tech) |
|-------|------------------------|-------------------------------------|
| **Junior IC** | 0.02-0.05% | $10K-$50K |
| **Mid IC** | 0.05-0.15% | $50K-$150K |
| **Senior IC** | 0.15-0.30% | $150K-$350K |
| **Staff IC** | 0.20-0.40% | $350K-$600K |
| **Principal IC** | 0.30-0.60% | $500K-$1M+ |
| **Director** | 0.25-0.40% | $400K-$800K |
| **VP** | 0.50-1.00% | $800K-$2M |
| **C-Suite** | 1.00-3.00% | $2M-$5M+ |
*Ranges are at Series B stage. Earlier: higher percentages, lower valuations. Later: lower percentages, higher valuations.*
### Vesting Schedules
| Schedule | Standard | Alternative |
|----------|----------|-------------|
| **Cliff (initial)** | 1 year | None (rare; attracts risk of early departures) |
| **Vesting (full)** | 4 years | 3 years (faster liquidity for talent), 5 years (longer retention) |
| **Vesting type** | Monthly (standard) | Quarterly (simpler admin), Annual (very rare) |
| **Acceleration** | Single trigger (acquired: unvested accelerates) | Double trigger (acquired + terminated: unvested accelerates) |
## Leveling & Career Banding
### Comp Band Structure
| Level | Title (Engineering example) | Base band | Equity band | Total comp target |
|-------|----------------------------|-----------|-------------|-------------------|
| L3 | Junior Engineer | $80K-$120K | $10K-$30K/yr | $90K-$150K |
| L4 | Engineer | $100K-$150K | $30K-$60K/yr | $130K-$210K |
| L5 | Senior Engineer | $130K-$190K | $60K-$120K/yr | $190K-$310K |
| L6 | Staff Engineer | $160K-$230K | $120K-$200K/yr | $280K-$430K |
| L7 | Principal Engineer | $190K-$280K | $200K-$350K/yr | $390K-$630K |
### Compensation Philosophy Principles
1. **Pay for performance, not tenure** — Raises and bonuses correlate with impact, not time in seat
2. **Transparent bands** — Employees know the range for their level, reducing negotiation advantage and bias
3. **Internal equity** — Similar contribution receives similar comp regardless of negotiation skill or tenure
4. **Market-driven** — Bands adjust with market, not by individual request
5. **Total comp mindset** — Base + bonus + equity + benefits = total value. Communicate it that way.
## Variable Pay & Incentives
| Type | Who | Structure | Payout |
|------|-----|-----------|--------|
| **Annual bonus** | All employees | % of base (10-20% IC, 20-50% exec) | Based on company + individual performance |
| **Sales commission** | Sales team | % of ARR/bookings (10-20% SMB, 5-10% enterprise) | Paid on closed deals |
| **Spot bonus** | Any | One-time cash award ($500-$5,000) | Immediate recognition |
| **Retention bonus** | Critical at-risk talent | Lump sum with clawback | At anniversary or milestone |
| **Sign-on bonus** | New hires | One-time cash + possible clawback | At start date |
## Compensation Reviews
| Review type | Cadence | What changes |
|-------------|---------|-------------|
| **Merit increase** | Annual | Base salary adjustment (3-5% typical, higher for high performers) |
| **Promotion** | As earned | Level change, base increase (10-20% typical), equity refresh |
| **Equity refresh** | Annual or on promotion | Additional equity grant (new vesting schedule) |
| **Market correction** | Ad hoc | Base adjustment when market moves significantly between reviews |
| **Cost of living adjustment** | Annual (if separate from merit) | Across-the-board % increase |