c70bcbf6b4 Direction round: verdict-routed hand, MY PICK card, salience parity, Safer/Bolder registers (#531)
* Route the direction hand by verdict, add the pick card, enforce salience parity

The decision round previously rendered every dealt challenger as an equal
full card whatever the weighing said, so a world that fused poorly (an
underwater world dealt to a flower shop) sat at the same visual weight as
the assigned direction, and concept-level fusion had no surviving output.
Three changes, all presentation-layer; the dice, the assignment, and the
two-axis weighing are untouched:

- Verdict routing: the weighing closes with wins / competitive / declined
  per challenger, decided before any borrowing. Declined challengers render
  demoted (narrow, quiet, catalog art as a labeled thumb, "Adopt anyway"),
  reordered to the end of the deck by the page itself, still adoptable,
  never silently dropped. Donations return as named "raised by" lines on
  the assigned card: a declined challenger donates ambition and system
  discipline, never its clothes.

- The pick card: one card for the model's top-ranked grounded candidate
  when the dice assigned another, kicker MY PICK, honest familiarity risk
  on its face. One card, never a ranked list, never the lead position; the
  anti-menu rule survives with exactly this carve-out.

- Salience parity: a card's imagery weight is capped by the assigned
  card's. With a text-only assigned card (no image generation in the
  harness), full-bleed catalog heroes demote to labeled thumbs, so what
  looks important is the verdict's call, never rendering luck.

serve-question payload gains additive fields (verdict, kept, raised); old
payloads render unchanged. concept-seed's rendered instructions carry the
verdict/donation contract and the pick-card carve-out. Covered by two
Playwright tests in the new-work e2e suite (verdict routing + parity).

Design exploration and rationale were worked through with the maintainer;
research grounding is impeccable.style/research lessons 3-5.

AI-assisted change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Code <noreply@anthropic.com>

* Add Safer/Bolder re-roll registers to the direction round

The re-roll gains the user's steering wheel on the familiar-to-bold axis.
The decision page renders two register buttons beside the plain re-roll
(payload: reroll: { registers: ["safer", "bolder"] }; booleans still work),
the answer carries the chosen register, and concept-seed gains --register.

The design constraint that shaped the implementation: a register changes
only what a round INSTRUCTS, never what it DEALT. The same key and reroll
count reproduce the same deal whatever the register, so the exclusion chain
never forks and the reproduction contract holds with no API change.

- bolder: the dealt foreign forms become the whole hand, every challenger a
  full card; the first-dealt challenger leads (assignment by deal order, so
  the dice still choose). The pick card sits out; the canon stays.
- safer: the round's dealt hand is spent unseen and stays excluded; the
  model presents its remaining conventional grounded candidates (at most
  three) plus the canon executed against named competitors. This is the one
  sanctioned lineup of the model's own ranked list, existing only by
  explicit user request. Works degraded (needs no catalog); bolder degrades
  to a plain grounded round, disclosed.

Registers are user steering, never the model's to pre-select. Covered by a
concept-seed unit test (same-deal invariant, validation) and a Playwright
test (button, answer field, REGISTER directive).

AI-assisted change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Code <noreply@anthropic.com>

* Add the execution-contract round: comp-led or code-led, chosen after the direction

The build previously went comp-led for everyone, silently: a generated comp
led and the build chased it, which produces the boldest compositions and
also the measured worst-of-both-worlds failure (ambitious design landed
poorly, no motion, fix rounds after). Models already defect from it by
quietly skipping comp generation, which is unsanctioned code-led with no
contract to catch it. This makes the fork explicit and both paths
defection-proof:

- Comp-led: the comp is law and non-optional once chosen; visualize.md and
  the comp-is-king build phases run as today.
- Code-led: no comp of this page, skipped by contract rather than drift.
  The QUALITY BAR boards still calibrate finish, and the ambition moves
  into the written direction contract (FIRST VIEWPORT plus a named
  signature interaction and motion grammar), audited by the finish
  reviewer in behavior. Not a discount on commitment.

Placement: a second round on the same open table, right after the
direction lands. Sketches stay in the direction round (they pick the
world); comps are what code-led skips (they bind the composition). The
chosen world sets the default lead; the user flips freely; a standing
preference recorded in PRODUCT.md skips the round on later surfaces; with
no image generation there is no fork, code-led is the only path.

Mechanism: serve-question gains payload-level followup: true, which keeps
the detached server alive after a pick (exactly like re-roll), swaps the
page to the loading hand instead of goodbye, marks the answer with
followup: true so --wait keeps the table, and prints a FOLLOWUP OPEN
directive telling the agent to deliver the next round via --update.
Covered by a Playwright test driving the full two-round flow.

AI-assisted change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Code <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix: address PR review bot findings

- Degraded safer register no longer contradicts itself (greptile,
  Copilot, cursor): the degraded template previously said "the assigned
  index is suspended; the user picks" and then emitted ASSIGNED INDEX,
  the mandatory build instruction, and the restated footer anyway. The
  degraded safer path now suppresses the assignment machinery entirely,
  matching the non-degraded safer round, and restates the user-picks
  behavior for truncated readers instead.
- A declined card's declared sketch no longer renders a full media face
  (Copilot): the renderer ignores sketch slots on declined cards
  outright, so a stray sketch cannot buy back the salience the verdict
  took away.
- Bolder rounds no longer carry the generic weighing instruction
  (cursor): it measures against the assigned grounded direction, which
  the bolder register suspends; a leader-relative variant weighs the
  fused challengers against the first-dealt leader instead.

All three pinned by new assertions in tests/concept-seed.test.mjs and
tests/new-work-e2e.test.mjs.

AI-assisted change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Code <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix: followup never arms the loading hand in blocking serve mode

cursor[bot] caught a client/server disagreement: the page interpolated its
FOLLOWUP constant from the payload alone, so a followup: true payload served
in blocking mode (no --start) would leave the browser on a loading hand that
nothing resolves, since a blocking server exits on any pick and has no
update channel. The page constant is now armed only when the server is
detached, blocking rounds get the goodbye screen as before, and new-work.md
states that followup belongs only on a detached round; blocking and
structured-tool channels run the build-path round as its own second
question. Pinned in tests/serve-question.test.mjs.

AI-assisted change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Code <noreply@anthropic.com>

* Add card-kind choice telemetry and the bolder routing disambiguation

The choice ping previously fired only when a dealt catalog challenger won,
so pick-share and canon-share had no denominator and the decision page's
new spectrum could not be measured. The ping now fires once per resolved
attended round on API-dealt rolls: --kind names which card class won
(assigned / pick / challenger / canon), --chosen carries the catalog id
only when a dealt challenger won, and --register rides along when the
round came from a steered hand. Grounded candidates' names never leave the
machine (the ping carries the kind alone), the legacy id-only shape stays
valid, and DO_NOT_TRACK / IMPECCABLE_NO_TELEMETRY still disable the ping
entirely. The seed's TELEMETRY block teaches the new invocation.

Also the naming-collision guard: "bolder" said while a direction round is
open routes to the Bolder hand register, never the bolder refinement
command; one line each in bolder.md and new-work.md.

The /api/chosen field additions land in a sister impeccable-site PR; the
API ignores unknown fields meanwhile, so this is safe to ship first.

AI-assisted change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Code <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix: ping test survives a DO_NOT_TRACK shell

cursor[bot]: the pingChosen unit test cleared only IMPECCABLE_NO_TELEMETRY,
so a developer shell with DO_NOT_TRACK set failed the success-path
assertions. The test now clears both, restores prior values in finally,
and passes under DO_NOT_TRACK=1.

AI-assisted change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Code <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Code <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-08 14:17:21 -07:00
2026-08-05 22:27:35 +00:00
2026-08-05 22:27:35 +00:00
2026-08-05 22:27:35 +00:00
2026-08-05 22:27:35 +00:00
2026-08-05 22:27:35 +00:00
2026-07-29 14:28:14 -07:00
2026-07-31 18:02:17 +02:00

Impeccable

Design guidance for AI coding agents. 1 skill, 23 commands, live browser iteration, and 59 deterministic detector rules for AI-generated frontend design.

Quick start: From your project root, run npx impeccable install, then run /impeccable init inside your AI coding tool. Full docs: impeccable.style.

Why Impeccable?

Anthropic's frontend-design was the first widely-used design skill for Claude. Impeccable started from there.

Every model trained on the same SaaS templates. Skip the guidance and you get the same handful of tells on every project: Inter for everything, purple-to-blue gradients, cards nested in cards, gray text on colored backgrounds, the rounded-square icon tile above every heading.

Impeccable adds:

  • One setup flow. /impeccable init writes PRODUCT.md and offers DESIGN.md, so later commands know the audience, brand/product lane, voice, anti-references, colors, type, and components.
  • 23 commands. A shared design vocabulary with your AI: polish, audit, critique, distill, animate, bolder, quieter, and more.
  • 59 deterministic detector rules plus LLM-only critique checks. The CLI and browser extension run the deterministic rules with no LLM and no API key.

What's Included

The Skill: impeccable

The skill installs as one command:

/impeccable <command> <target>

Start every new project with:

/impeccable init

init asks whether the surface is brand (marketing, landing, portfolio) or product (app UI, dashboard, tool), then writes design context that every later command reads.

23 Commands

All commands are accessed through /impeccable:

Command What it does
/impeccable craft Full shape-then-build flow with visual iteration
/impeccable init One-time setup: gather design context, write PRODUCT.md and DESIGN.md, configure live mode, recommend next steps
/impeccable document Generate root DESIGN.md from existing project code
/impeccable extract Pull reusable components and tokens into the design system
/impeccable shape Plan UX/UI before writing code
/impeccable critique UX design review: hierarchy, clarity, emotional resonance
/impeccable audit Run technical quality checks (a11y, performance, responsive)
/impeccable polish Final pass, design system alignment, and shipping readiness
/impeccable bolder Amplify boring designs
/impeccable quieter Tone down overly bold designs
/impeccable distill Strip to essence
/impeccable harden Error handling, i18n, text overflow, edge cases
/impeccable onboard First-run flows, empty states, activation paths
/impeccable animate Add purposeful motion
/impeccable colorize Introduce strategic color
/impeccable typeset Fix font choices, hierarchy, sizing
/impeccable layout Fix layout, spacing, visual rhythm
/impeccable delight Add moments of joy
/impeccable overdrive Add technically extraordinary effects
/impeccable clarify Improve unclear UX copy
/impeccable adapt Adapt for different devices
/impeccable optimize Performance improvements
/impeccable live Visual variant mode: iterate on elements in the browser

Use /impeccable pin <command> to create standalone shortcuts (e.g., pin audit creates /audit).

Usage Examples

/impeccable audit blog           # Audit blog hub + post pages
/impeccable critique landing     # UX design review
/impeccable polish settings      # Final pass before shipping
/impeccable harden checkout      # Add error handling + edge cases

Or use /impeccable directly with a description:

/impeccable redo this hero section

Anti-Patterns

The skill includes explicit guidance on what to avoid:

  • Don't use overused fonts (Arial, Inter, system defaults)
  • Don't use gray text on colored backgrounds
  • Don't use pure black/gray (always tint)
  • Don't wrap everything in cards or nest cards inside cards
  • Don't use bounce/elastic easing (feels dated)

See It In Action

Visit the Neo Mirai case study to see a before/after case study of a real project transformed with Impeccable commands.

Installation

From the root of your project, run:

npx impeccable install

This shows the harness folders it detected (for example ~/.claude, ~/.codex, ~/.grok, or project-local .cursor), lets you keep the detected set or customize providers, then asks whether to install into the current project or globally. Use --providers=claude,codex,cursor,grok and --scope=project|global to skip those choices in scripts. On Claude Code, Cursor, Codex, GitHub Copilot, and Grok Build, it also installs the provider-native hook manifest for the current project. Works with Cursor, Claude Code, Gemini CLI, Codex CLI, Grok Build, and every other supported tool. Reload your harness afterward.

To refresh an existing install, run:

npx impeccable update

Codex users should open /hooks after install or update and approve the project hook when prompted. Codex tracks trust by hook definition, so updates that change .codex/hooks.json can require approval again. Grok Build users need project folder trust (/hooks-trust or launch with --trust) before .grok/hooks/ scripts run.

Option 2: Git Submodule

For teams that want to keep Impeccable vendored and updated through Git, add this repo as a submodule and link the compiled provider build into your harness folders:

git submodule add https://github.com/pbakaus/impeccable .impeccable
npx impeccable link --source=.impeccable --providers=claude,cursor
git add .gitmodules .impeccable .claude .cursor
git commit -m "Add Impeccable skills"

Use the providers your project needs, for example claude, cursor, gemini, codex, github, grok, opencode, pi, qoder, trae, trae-cn, rovo-dev, or vibe. The command links individual skill folders from .impeccable/dist/universal/ and leaves existing real skill directories untouched unless you pass --force.

To update later:

git submodule update --remote .impeccable
npx impeccable link --source=.impeccable --providers=claude,cursor

Option 3: Plugin install

Claude Code:

/plugin marketplace add pbakaus/impeccable

Claude Code only. After adding the marketplace, open /plugin and install Impeccable from the list.

Grok Build:

grok plugin install pbakaus/impeccable#plugin --trust

Grok Build only. The #plugin suffix installs the slim plugin package (skills, agents, and hooks) instead of the full monorepo. Then run /impeccable init in a Grok session. Project-scoped installs via npx impeccable install --providers=grok also work and write .grok/skills/ plus .grok/hooks/impeccable.json.

Option 4: Download from Website

Visit impeccable.style, download the ZIP for your tool, and extract to your project.

Option 5: Copy from Repository

Cursor:

cp -r dist/cursor/.cursor your-project/

Note: Cursor skills require setup:

  1. Switch to Nightly channel in Cursor Settings → Beta
  2. Enable Agent Skills in Cursor Settings → Rules

Learn more about Cursor skills

Claude Code:

# Project-specific
cp -r dist/claude-code/.claude your-project/

# Or global (applies to all projects)
cp -r dist/claude-code/.claude/* ~/.claude/

OpenCode:

cp -r dist/opencode/.opencode your-project/

Pi:

cp -r dist/pi/.pi your-project/

Gemini CLI:

cp -r dist/gemini/.gemini your-project/

Note: Gemini CLI skills require setup:

  1. Install preview version: npm i -g @google/gemini-cli@preview
  2. Run /settings and enable "Skills"
  3. Run /skills list to verify installation

Learn more about Gemini CLI skills

Codex CLI:

# Project-local
cp -r dist/agents/.agents your-project/
mkdir -p your-project/.codex
cp dist/codex/.codex/hooks.json your-project/.codex/hooks.json

# Or install the skill user-wide. Copy .codex/hooks.json into each project
# where you want the design hook to run.
mkdir -p ~/.agents/skills
cp -r dist/agents/.agents/skills/* ~/.agents/skills/

The asset-producer subagent ships nested inside the skill's own agents/ folder, which Codex auto-discovers. No separate .codex/agents/ copy is needed. The hook is project-local because Codex discovers hooks from .codex/hooks.json next to trusted project config.

GitHub Copilot:

cp -r dist/github/.github your-project/

Trae:

# Trae China (domestic version)
cp -r dist/trae/.trae-cn/skills/* ~/.trae-cn/skills/

# Trae International
cp -r dist/trae/.trae/skills/* ~/.trae/skills/

Note: Trae has two versions with different config directories:

  • Trae China: ~/.trae-cn/skills/
  • Trae International: ~/.trae/skills/

After copying, restart Trae IDE to activate the skills.

Rovo Dev:

# Project-specific
cp -r dist/rovo-dev/.rovodev your-project/

# Or global (applies to all projects)
cp -r dist/rovo-dev/.rovodev/skills/* ~/.rovodev/skills/

Qoder:

# Project-specific
cp -r dist/qoder/.qoder your-project/

# Or global (applies to all projects)
cp -r dist/qoder/.qoder/skills/* ~/.qoder/skills/

Mistral Vibe:

# Project-specific
cp -r dist/vibe/.vibe your-project/

# Or global (applies to all projects)
cp -r dist/vibe/.vibe/skills/* ~/.vibe/skills/

Grok Build:

# Project-specific
cp -r dist/grok/.grok your-project/

# Or global (applies to all projects)
cp -r dist/grok/.grok/skills/* ~/.grok/skills/

Prefer npx impeccable install --providers=grok or grok plugin install pbakaus/impeccable#plugin --trust so the design hook installs too. Project hooks need /hooks-trust (or --trust) once per folder.

Google Antigravity:

# Project-specific
cp -r dist/antigravity/.agent your-project/

# Or global (applies to all projects)
mkdir -p ~/.gemini/config/skills
cp -r dist/antigravity/.agent/skills/* ~/.gemini/config/skills/

Usage

Once installed, every command runs through the single /impeccable skill:

/impeccable audit        # Find issues
/impeccable polish       # Final cleanup
/impeccable distill      # Remove complexity
/impeccable critique     # Full design review

Type /impeccable alone to see the full command list.

Most commands accept an optional argument to focus on a specific area:

/impeccable audit the header
/impeccable polish the checkout form

If you reach for one command often, pin it with /impeccable pin audit to get /audit as a standalone shortcut.

Note: Codex uses skills here, not /prompts: commands. Open /skills or type $impeccable. Repo-local installs live in .agents/skills/; user-wide installs live in ~/.agents/skills/. GitHub Copilot uses .github/skills/. Restart the tool if a newly installed skill does not appear.

Keeping .impeccable out of git

As you run commands, Impeccable writes working files under .impeccable/: critique and polish screenshots, live-mode session and preview state, runtime caches, and per-developer config. Most of it is ephemeral and should not be committed, while a few files are shared project artifacts that belong in the repo. Add this block to your project's .gitignore:

# impeccable-ignore-start
# Ephemeral output, runtime state, and per-dev overrides.
# Unanchored: .impeccable may sit at the repo root or under a nested
# workspace (apps/web/.impeccable/...); anchored patterns would miss it.
# Shared artifacts stay tracked: config.json, live/config.json,
# design.json, critique/*.md.
.impeccable/config.local.json
.impeccable/hook.cache.json
.impeccable/hook.pending.json
.impeccable/*.png
.impeccable/live/server.json
.impeccable/live/sessions/
.impeccable/live/previews/
.impeccable/live/annotations/
.impeccable/live/cache/
.impeccable/live/manual-edit-apply-transaction.json
.impeccable/live/manual-edit-events.jsonl
.impeccable/live/manual-edit-evidence/
.impeccable/live/pending-manual-edits.json
.impeccable/live/deferred-svelte-component-accepts.json
.impeccable/live/*.png
# impeccable-ignore-end

The block is wrapped in # impeccable-ignore-start / # impeccable-ignore-end markers so you can recognize and refresh it later. Patterns are unanchored on purpose: in a monorepo the active project (and its .impeccable/ directory) often lives under a nested workspace path like apps/web/, and a root-anchored pattern would miss it.

Keep these tracked (they are shared project artifacts, do not add them to .gitignore):

  • .impeccable/config.json (unified shared config)
  • .impeccable/live/config.json (live-mode framework wiring)
  • .impeccable/design.json (shared design spec)
  • .impeccable/critique/*.md (review reports)

If an ephemeral file (a screenshot, config.local.json) was committed before you added the block, .gitignore will not untrack it automatically. Run git rm --cached <path> to stop tracking it without deleting your local copy.

Design hook

On Claude Code, GitHub Copilot, Codex, Cursor, and Grok Build, npx impeccable install and npx impeccable update install a provider-native hook manifest along with the skill payload. The hook runs the Impeccable design detector on direct UI file edits and surfaces findings back into the agent flow. Claude Code, GitHub Copilot, Codex, and Grok Build surface findings after the edit (and run a deeper pass on Stop where supported). Cursor blocks bad proposed writes before they land.

Installed hook surfaces:

  • Claude Code: .claude/settings.local.json (gitignored, machine-local) runs ${CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR}/.claude/skills/impeccable/scripts/hook.mjs. A hook moved into the shared settings.json is honored in place.
  • GitHub Copilot: .github/hooks/impeccable.json (committed, shared by the Copilot CLI and the cloud agent) runs .github/skills/impeccable/scripts/hook.mjs. The Copilot CLI activates it once the file is on the repository's default branch and the folder is trusted.
  • Cursor: .cursor/hooks.json runs .cursor/skills/impeccable/scripts/hook-before-edit.mjs.
  • Codex: .codex/hooks.json runs .agents/skills/impeccable/scripts/hook.mjs.

The installer preserves unrelated hook entries and settings. If a hook manifest is malformed, install/update aborts by default; rerun with --force to back up the malformed file as .bak and replace it.

On an interactive install/update, Impeccable explains the hook and offers to install it (default yes). Your choice is remembered per-developer in the gitignored .impeccable/config.local.json, so you are not asked again; --no-hooks skips it for that run without recording anything. Hook lifecycle settings live under the hook key of .impeccable/config.json; detector ignores live under detector, shared by /impeccable hooks and npx impeccable detect.

For debugging, set hook.auditLog in .impeccable/config.json to a path (or the legacy IMPECCABLE_HOOK_LOG env var) to write one NDJSON line per hook invocation. Leave it unset for normal use.

Codex requires one platform step that Impeccable cannot safely skip: open /hooks after install or update and approve the project hook. There is no Codex marketplace/plugin install flow for this hook.

Full hook docs: impeccable.style/docs/hooks.

Manual copy commands are fallback/debug instructions. The normal path is:

npx impeccable install
npx impeccable update

CLI

Impeccable includes a standalone CLI for detecting anti-patterns without an AI harness:

npx impeccable detect src/                   # scan a directory
npx impeccable detect index.html             # scan an HTML file
npx impeccable detect https://example.com    # scan a URL (Puppeteer)
npx impeccable detect --json .               # CI-friendly JSON output
npx impeccable detect --no-config src/       # raw scan, ignoring project config/context
npx impeccable ignores list                  # show detector ignores
npx impeccable ignores add-file "src/legacy/**"
npx impeccable ignores add-value overused-font Inter --reason "Brand font"

The detector catches 59 deterministic issues across AI slop (side-tab borders, purple gradients, bounce easing, dark glows) and general design quality (line length, cramped padding, small touch targets, skipped headings, and more).

By default, detect respects the same .impeccable/config.json and .impeccable/config.local.json detector config as the design hook: detector.ignoreRules, detector.ignoreFiles, detector.ignoreValues, and detector.designSystem.enabled. Hook lifecycle settings such as hook.enabled only affect automatic hook execution.

For a waiver that should travel with one file instead of the repo config, add an inline comment in the file: <!-- impeccable-disable overused-font: exported brand doc -->. The marker works in any comment syntax, scopes to the whole file (or one line with impeccable-disable-line / impeccable-disable-next-line), and is bypassed by --no-inline-ignores or --no-config.

Full detector docs: impeccable.style/docs/detector.

Supported Tools

Community & Ecosystem

Join the community and ecosystem conversations:

  • GitHub Discussions: file bugs, request features, and help newcomers.
  • Impeccable on npm: grab the CLI, follow releases, and star the package.
  • Follow @pbakaus on Twitter for release notes, sample lint reports, and video highlights of new rules.

Contributing

See DEVELOP.md for contributor guidelines and build instructions.

License

Apache 2.0. See LICENSE.


Created by Paul Bakaus

S
Description
No description provided
Readme
378 MiB
Languages
JavaScript 75.7%
Rust 22.1%
Shell 0.9%
Batchfile 0.9%
CSS 0.2%
Other 0.1%